Skip to content 
When it comes to securing your home, choosing the right deadbolt lock can make a big difference for your peace of mind. In this article, you’ll explore a detailed comparison of two popular deadbolt options: the Schlage Single Cylinder Satin Nickel Deadbolt and the Kwikset SmartKey Satin Nickel Deadbolt. Koby from Silver Eagle Locksmith Las Vegas dives into the nuances of each, giving you an expert take on their pros and cons, as well as guidance on installation.
Both locks boast high-security ratings, but each has its unique strengths and drawbacks. While the Kwikset SmartKey excels in resisting lock-picking and bumping, the Schlage offers superior durability against drilling attempts. You’ll also find tips on installing either lock, making the process straightforward even for DIY enthusiasts. By the end, you’ll have a clearer idea of which deadbolt best suits your needs and how to get it up and running in no time.
Schlage vs Kwikset – Overview
Introduction to Schlage Single Cylinder Satin Nickel Deadbolt
The Schlage Single Cylinder Satin Nickel Deadbolt is a popular choice among homeowners seeking reliable security for their homes. This deadbolt features a solid metal construction, a smooth satin nickel finish, and a straightforward key-based locking mechanism. Schlage has been a trusted brand in the lock industry for many years, known for producing durable and secure locks. This particular model offers a blend of sleek aesthetics and robust security features.
Introduction to Kwikset SmartKey Satin Nickel Deadbolt
The Kwikset SmartKey Satin Nickel Deadbolt is designed for those who prioritize convenience and security. The SmartKey technology allows homeowners to rekey their locks quickly without needing to call a locksmith. This feature makes Kwikset an excellent choice for those who frequently change keys due to shared living arrangements or lost keys. The satin nickel finish adds a modern touch to the lock’s appearance, making it an attractive option for contemporary homes.
Ease of Purchase
Availability in Hardware Stores
Both Schlage and Kwikset deadbolts are widely available in hardware stores across the country. Whether you visit a large chain like Home Depot or a local mom-and-pop hardware store, you will likely find these locks in stock. This widespread availability makes it easy for you to purchase and replace locks as needed without having to wait for delivery times.
Online Purchase Options
In addition to their physical store availability, both Schlage and Kwikset deadbolts can be purchased online. Major e-commerce sites such as Amazon, eBay, and the websites of large hardware retailers offer a variety of models from both brands. Online purchases can be particularly convenient if you live in remote areas or prefer the ease of home delivery. Customer reviews and detailed product information available online can also help you make an informed decision.
Security Rating
BHMA Security Ratings for Schlage
The Builders Hardware Manufacturers Association (BHMA) provides security ratings for locks, and Schlage deadbolts typically receive high marks. A common rating for Schlage locks is Grade 1, which is the highest level of security offered by BHMA. This rating ensures that the lock has undergone rigorous testing for durability, strength, and resistance to tampering.
BHMA Security Ratings for Kwikset
Kwikset deadbolts also perform well in BHMA security ratings, often securing a Grade 1 or Grade 2 rating. While Kwikset locks are highly secure, their primary focus is on innovative features such as the SmartKey technology. Despite the advanced features, these locks meet the stringent standards set by BHMA to ensure reliable security.
Quality Comparison
Materials Used in Schlage Deadbolt
Schlage deadbolts are constructed using high-quality metallic components. The internal mechanisms are designed to withstand significant wear and tear, while the exterior is often made from hardened steel. This robust construction helps increase the longevity and durability of Schlage locks, making them a reliable choice for securing your home.
Materials Used in Kwikset Deadbolt
Kwikset deadbolts are constructed with a combination of metal and high-strength plastic components. While the use of plastic makes some parts of the lock lighter, it does not compromise overall security. The high-strength plastic used in Kwikset locks contributes to the ease of rekeying and other advanced features without sacrificing security and durability.
Security Aspects
Security Features of Schlage
Schlage deadbolts come with a myriad of security features. These include anti-pick pins, hardened steel bolt construction, and drill-resistant plates. These features make Schlage locks resilient against common methods of forced entry. Additionally, the locks have reinforced strike plates, which further enhance their resistance to tampering and break-ins.
Security Features of Kwikset
Kwikset’s SmartKey technology is a standout feature, allowing you to easily rekey the lock without specialized tools or skills. This is particularly useful if you need to change keys regularly. Kwikset deadbolts also include anti-pick and anti-bump features, making them highly resistant to these forms of attack.
Lock-Picking and Bumping Resistance
When it comes to lock-picking and bumping resistance, Kwikset SmartKey deadbolts tend to fare better. The SmartKey technology includes a side-locking bar that makes it more challenging for traditional lock-picking tools to manipulate the pins. Schlage locks, while still secure, are relatively easier to pick and bump compared to Kwikset.
Drill Resistance Comparison
Drill resistance is an essential factor in judging the security of a lock. Schlage deadbolts feature stronger metal components and dedicated drill-resistant plates, which make them harder to breach using a drill. On the other hand, although Kwikset advertises certain models as drill-resistant, their use of plastic components makes them somewhat more vulnerable to drilling when compared to Schlage locks.
Pros and Cons
Pros and Cons of Schlage
Pros:
- High security due to solid metal construction
- Resistant to drilling attacks
- Professional locksmith rekeying minimizes the chance of errors
- Trusted brand with broad recognition
Cons:
- Easier to pick and bump compared to Kwikset SmartKey
- Requires professional rekeying, which can be inconvenient and costly
Pros and Cons of Kwikset
Pros:
- SmartKey technology allows for easy DIY rekeying
- Highly resistant to lock-picking and bumping attacks
- Convenient for homeowners who frequently need to change keys
Cons:
- Easier to drill due to plastic components in the lock
- DIY rekeying can go wrong, leading to lock malfunctions
Locksmith Recommendations
Professional Perspective on Schlage
Locksmiths generally have a high regard for Schlage deadbolts. They appreciate the robust build quality and the reliable security features that make these locks difficult to breach through non-destructive means like drilling. The necessity for professional rekeying is viewed favorably as it reduces the chance of errors, ensuring that the lock remains secure.
Professional Perspective on Kwikset
Kwikset locks are praised for their innovative SmartKey technology, which provides a high level of convenience and security. However, locksmiths often caution about the potential risks associated with DIY rekeying. While the system works well in theory, user errors can result in lock failures, necessitating professional intervention to correct.
Which Lock is Preferred by Locksmiths
In general, locksmiths tend to prefer Schlage deadbolts over Kwikset for their all-around security, durability, and fewer issues related to user error. The higher resistance to drilling makes Schlage a better choice for protecting your home against forced entry. While Kwikset offers convenience and advanced features, Schlage’s robustness and reliability seal the deal for many professionals.
Installation Guide
Tools Needed for Installation
Before you start the installation of either the Schlage or Kwikset deadbolt, you’ll need the following tools:
- Screwdriver (Phillips and Flathead)
- Measuring tape
- Pencil
- Drill (optional, depending on your door’s pre-drilling)
- Chisels (for the strike plate and deadbolt if necessary)
Step-by-Step Installation of Schlage Deadbolt
- Prepare the Door: Ensure that your door has the appropriate borehole and backset. Measure and mark as needed.
- Insert Deadbolt: Place the deadbolt mechanism into the borehole and secure it with screws.
- Install Exterior Plate: Align the exterior plate and insert the connecting spindle through the deadbolt.
- Attach Interior Plate: Align the interior plate with the spindle and secure it with the provided screws.
- Install Strike Plate: Align the strike plate with the bolt on the door frame and secure it with screws.
- Test the Lock: Ensure that the deadbolt operates smoothly by locking and unlocking the door.
Step-by-Step Installation of Kwikset SmartKey Deadbolt
- Prepare the Door: Check that your door has the correct borehole and backset measurements.
- Insert Deadbolt: Slide the deadbolt mechanism into the borehole and secure it with screws.
- Attach Exterior Assembly: Place the exterior assembly through the hole, ensuring the keyhole faces outwards.
- Attach Interior Assembly: Align the interior assembly with the spindle and secure it with screws.
- Install Strike Plate: Position the strike plate on the door frame and secure it tightly with screws.
- Set SmartKey: Use the SmartKey tool to rekey the lock as desired, following the manufacturer’s instructions.
- Test the Lock: Confirm that the lock operates correctly by turning the key and engaging the deadbolt.
Importance of Strike Plate for Security
The strike plate is a critical component of your door’s security. It is the part that receives the latch or deadbolt and mounts to the door frame. A heavy-duty strike plate can significantly enhance the resistance of your door to kick-ins and forced entries. Ensure that the strike plate is properly installed and screwed into the door frame using long screws for added strength.
Demonstration of Lock Picking
How to Pick a Schlage Deadbolt
Picking a Schlage deadbolt involves using specialized tools such as lock picks and tension wrenches. The process includes inserting a tension wrench into the keyway and applying slight pressure. Then, you use a pick tool to manipulate the pins inside the lock until they reach the shear line, allowing the lock to turn. The Schlage deadbolt’s construction can make this process straightforward for an experienced lock picker but challenging for amateurs.
Using Lishi Picking Tool
The Lishi picking tool is a specialized device that makes picking locks more accessible by decoding the lock’s pin positions. It is particularly effective for locks with complex mechanisms. Using a Lishi tool on a Schlage deadbolt would involve inserting the tool into the keyway, applying tension, and then manipulating the internal pins according to the tool’s readings.
Ethical Considerations in Demonstrating Lock Picking
Demonstrating lock picking must be done with a sense of responsibility and awareness of its ethical implications. Lock picking should only be practiced on locks you own or have explicit permission to manipulate. Sharing detailed lock-picking information in public forums can potentially fall into the wrong hands, leading to unauthorized entries and theft. Therefore, any educational content about lock-picking should emphasize responsible use and awareness.
Conclusion
Summary of Key Points
Both Schlage and Kwikset deadbolts offer high levels of security, with each having its strengths and weaknesses. Schlage excels in overall durability and drill resistance, making it a preferred choice for many locksmiths. Kwikset, with its SmartKey technology, offers unparalleled convenience and the ease of rekeying, which is ideal for DIY enthusiasts.
Final Thoughts on Schlage and Kwikset Deadbolts
Ultimately, the choice between Schlage and Kwikset depends on what you value more: the rock-solid durability and reduced user error of Schlage or the cutting-edge convenience and features of Kwikset. While Schlage might be more expensive due to the need for professional rekeying, the investment can pay off in terms of robust and reliable home security. Conversely, if you prefer handling tasks yourself and want to enjoy state-of-the-art rekeying technology, Kwikset SmartKey is an excellent option. Consider your unique needs and security priorities when choosing the right deadbolt for your home.
